Why are medical negligence cases that are settled outside of court kept off doctors records?
Medical Negligence
29 April 2026
min read
Key Takeaways
Settlements reached outside of court do not appear on a doctor’s practitioner record, creating opacity around patterns of repeated negligence claims. This article discusses the Dr Peter Kim case where settlement concealed multiple negligence findings.
• Settled medical negligence cases do not require publication of negligence claims or findings
• Dr Peter Kim had been sued for negligence multiple times but settled all cases outside court, leaving no public record
• One settlement involved $20,000 in repair surgery costs following improper breast augmentation procedure
• Independent medical assessment found procedure was completed improperly, with wrong implant size and inadequate post-operative care
Ashley Blundell underwent breast augmentation surgery in 2013 at the hands of Dr Peter Kim.
Two weeks after her surgery Ashley began to feel very unwell, she was experiencing fevers and chills and one of her breasts had begun to slip causing her incision to open.
When her breast “exploded” she noticed that her breast was badly infected. At this stage Ashley knew something had gone wrong with her surgery. After getting her implants removed she decided to sue Dr Peter Kim for negligence and for the cost of a number of repair surgeries amounting to at least $20,000.
Ashley ended up settling her negligence claim outside of court.
However, she later found out that this was not Dr Peter Kim’s first negligence case and he had in fact been sued for negligence a number of times previously, but had always settled outside of court.
What does Settling Outside of Court do?
By settling outside of court Dr Peter Kim was able to avoid having his negligence recorded on his practitioner record.
By settling outside of court it is as if the negligence case never existed and the negligent acts never occurred, even though in Ashley’s case an independent medical professional found that Dr Peter Kim had not completed the procedure properly, put the wrong size implants in, and provided inadequate post-operative care.
No doubt there is an issue with this process. If the same doctor is being sued for negligence over and over again clearly something is not quite right with the practitioner and their standards.
Presently, the law surrounding this issue does not allow for publishing of negligence claims that settle inside, or outside of the court system.
This is an issue for the governing body of Doctors in Australia, the AMA. Clearly more needs to be done to cancel or suspend practicing licenses by Doctors who are repeatedly sued for negligence.
The same applies to any professional bodies including lawyers.
You might also be
interested in
Medical Negligence
29 April 2026
min read
How Can I Tell If My Injury Was Caused by Medical Negligence?
In this guide, we explain signs that can determine if your injury was caused by medical negligence. Find out if you have a case for compensation. Read now.
Medical Negligence
2 February 2026
min read
Medical Negligence Compensation in NSW: What You Can Claim
Have you suffered a
serious injury
Allowing seriously injured people to secure the compensation they deserve so they can return to enjoying life.
Unsure? Give us a call
What Our Clients
Are Saying
Featured Testimonial
I cannot speak highly enough of my experience with this workers Compensation team. When I first reached out, I was completely overwhelmed and unsure about the process. I hit rock bottom - unable to return to work, struggling emotionally, and feeling like I had no direction. From the very beginning, the solicitors were nothing short of amazing. They were patient, understanding and incredibly supportive at a time when I needed it most. They took the time to explain every step in a way I could understand, never making me feel rushed or alone. Their professionalism was matched only by their compassion and that combination made all the difference. Throughout the entire journey, I felt heard, respected and genuinely cared for. They fought for me when I didn’t have the strength to fight for myself and thanks to their dedication, I was able to get the outcome I needed to rebuild my life. If you’re unsure, scared or feeling lost like I was, I can confidently say you will be in the best hands with this team. They helped me through one of the hardest chapters of my life, and I am truly grateful. I can’t thank or recommend Garling & Co Lawyers enough.
Matthew Garling and his team have provided incredible support and guidance throughout my MVA damages claim this year, and I can’t thank them enough for making this journey feel like such a breeze. When I initially engaged Garling & co, I had no understanding of what was ahead. I was anxious and unsure about the process, while also navigating the physical challenges of my injuries. With assurance that my matter was being handled with high level of expertise, professionalism and integrity, I was able to focus on recovery instead. Throughout the process, Matthew and Allison have been honest, straightforward and efficient in all communication; being a supportive buffer in all dealings with the insurer, and consistently committed to a successful outcome. The outcome was excellent, and it is with huge relief and great thanks that I can put this matter behind me. I would highly recommend the services of Garling and co for any injury claims of a similar nature, and I’m forever grateful to Matthew and his team.
A big thank you to Matthew for his expertise, dedication, and genuine care in handling my matter. The outcome exceeded my expectations, and I am truly grateful for the excellent work of his entire team. Outstanding results - highly recommended.